๐งต Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad AS claim to be son of God?
@MansurXAhmed lies that Ahmad AS believed that God has a son. It doesn't say it anywhere!
1) In the SAME EXACT BOOK, Ahmad AS explains:
"Allah the Almighty is Holy, without a son. This revelation is metaphorical."
1/9
@MansurXAhmed lies that Ahmad AS believed that God has a son. It doesn't say it anywhere!
1) In the SAME EXACT BOOK, Ahmad AS explains:
"Allah the Almighty is Holy, without a son. This revelation is metaphorical."
1/9
2) GOD HAS A SON?
Even though Mansur lied, let's still take a look at the revelation:
"ุจูู ูููุฒูููุฉู ููููุฏูู"
"You are to Me LIKE My son"
When Isa AS is called "Son of God", he says that it is not literal but when Ahmad AS is called "LIKE my son", it becomes literal.
2/9
Even though Mansur lied, let's still take a look at the revelation:
"ุจูู ูููุฒูููุฉู ููููุฏูู"
"You are to Me LIKE My son"
When Isa AS is called "Son of God", he says that it is not literal but when Ahmad AS is called "LIKE my son", it becomes literal.
2/9
3) QURANIC EXAMPLE
In another book, Ahmad AS again denies the literalist explanation of this but Anti-Ahmadis like Mansur won't know.
"It must be remembered that God Almighty has no sons. However, this phrase is used here by way of allegorical and metaphorical expression."
3/9
In another book, Ahmad AS again denies the literalist explanation of this but Anti-Ahmadis like Mansur won't know.
"It must be remembered that God Almighty has no sons. However, this phrase is used here by way of allegorical and metaphorical expression."
3/9
3.1)
Ahmad AS further explains this in Istifta:
โGlory be to Allah and exalted is He from having a son, but this is a metaphor like His saying: 'Celebrate the praises of Allah as you celebrated the praises of your fathers' [2:201]. There are many metaphors..โ
4/9
Ahmad AS further explains this in Istifta:
โGlory be to Allah and exalted is He from having a son, but this is a metaphor like His saying: 'Celebrate the praises of Allah as you celebrated the praises of your fathers' [2:201]. There are many metaphors..โ
4/9
...in the Quran and there is no objection to them from the people of knowledge. So this saying is not objectionable, and you will find its like in the divine books and sayings of spiritual people called Sufis. So do not be hasty against us, O people of understanding."
5/9
5/9
4) SHAH WALIULLAH RH
"God has honored the prophets with titles like 'The Beloved(Mahbub)'. It is not, therefore, a matter of surprise if the word 'son' has been used in place of 'beloved'. But the Jews thought the honor was solely reserved for a Jew, Hebrew, and Israeli."
6/9
"God has honored the prophets with titles like 'The Beloved(Mahbub)'. It is not, therefore, a matter of surprise if the word 'son' has been used in place of 'beloved'. But the Jews thought the honor was solely reserved for a Jew, Hebrew, and Israeli."
6/9
5) IBN AL-UTHAYMIN
"All people are the family of Allah (ุงูุฎูู ุนูุงู ุงููู)"
He explains the above hadith:
"Allah provides for them, meaning He gives them their provision and takes care of them. It does not mean that He has children, glorified and exalted is He from that."
7/9
"All people are the family of Allah (ุงูุฎูู ุนูุงู ุงููู)"
He explains the above hadith:
"Allah provides for them, meaning He gives them their provision and takes care of them. It does not mean that He has children, glorified and exalted is He from that."
7/9
5) IMAM RAZI RH
Under the tafsir of Quran 9:60, Imam Razi RH uses the expression:
"ุฃูููู ุงููููููุฑูุงุกู ุนูููุงูู ุงูููู"
"Poor are the family of Allah"
This does not mean the literal family of Allah, rather, he explains it through the Quran 11:6 i.e. Allah provides for them.
8/9
Under the tafsir of Quran 9:60, Imam Razi RH uses the expression:
"ุฃูููู ุงููููููุฑูุงุกู ุนูููุงูู ุงูููู"
"Poor are the family of Allah"
This does not mean the literal family of Allah, rather, he explains it through the Quran 11:6 i.e. Allah provides for them.
8/9
CONCLUSION
- Ahmad AS did NOT say Allah has a son. Mansur lied.
- Mansur does NOT believe "Son of God" is literal when Isa AS says.
- The recipient of the revelation himself has said multiple times that the revelation is metaphorical, NOT literal.
- Quran & scholars agree.
9/9
- Ahmad AS did NOT say Allah has a son. Mansur lied.
- Mansur does NOT believe "Son of God" is literal when Isa AS says.
- The recipient of the revelation himself has said multiple times that the revelation is metaphorical, NOT literal.
- Quran & scholars agree.
9/9
Loading suggestions...