@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 1/20β ClimateFeedback dot org is a climate industry propaganda site, which has no credibility. That article is full of obvious disinformation.
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 2/20β E.g., they claim, "There is no science nor is there any data that globally support the assertion that ecosystems are thriving or that humanity would benefit from increasing temperature or increasing carbon dioxide."
This NASA video refutes that lie:
youtube.com
This NASA video refutes that lie:
youtube.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 3/20β The world is literally getting greener, largely thanks to anthropogenically elevated atmospheric CO2 levels. Here's a map:
sealevel.info
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 4/20β The IPCC's AR5 estimates that natural terrestrial CO2 uptake now exceeds natural CO2 emissions by a whopping 2.5 PgC per year. That's because elevated CO2 makes plants healthier and faster-growing.
#greening" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="event.stopPropagation()">sealevel.info
sealevel.info
#greening" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="event.stopPropagation()">sealevel.info
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 5/20β β₯1500 ppmv CO2 is optimal for most crops. That's why commercial greenhouses use CO2 generators to raise daytime CO2 concentration to about that level. They go to the expense because elevated CO2 (eCO2) makes crops MUCH healthier and more productive.
google.com
google.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 6/20β That's also about the CO2 concentration during the lush Cretaceous. It's believed to have been even higher during the equally lush Jurassic.
Extra CO2 is beneficial for almost all crops, dramatically so for most. Look what extra CO2 does for pine:
Extra CO2 is beneficial for almost all crops, dramatically so for most. Look what extra CO2 does for pine:
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 7/20β Elevated CO2 helps warm the Earth, but there's no convincing evidence that's harmful. In fact, scientists call warm climate periods "climate optimums."
Plus, elevated CO2 is VERY beneficial for agriculture β a fact known to science for >100 years.
tinyurl.com
Plus, elevated CO2 is VERY beneficial for agriculture β a fact known to science for >100 years.
tinyurl.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 8/20β Elevated CO2 improves crop yields & mitigates drought impacts. That's helping make famines rare for first time in human history.
ourworldindata.org
sealevel.info
ourworldindata.org
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 9/20β Are you old enough to remember when horrific famines (often caused by drought) were common in Africa and Asia? Have you noticed that you don't hear those news stories anymore?
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 10/20β Here's what manmade CO2 emissions and climate change are doing for Africa:
sealevel.info
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza 11/20β In 2009 @NatGeo reported, "Vast swaths of North Africa are getting noticeably lusher due to warming temperatures, new satellite images show, suggesting a possible boon for people living in the driest part of the continent."
sealevel.info
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 12/20β Elevated CO2 is one of the reasons famines have become rare. It is impossible to overstate that blessing's importance. Compare:
β The1918 flu pandemic killed β2% of world population.
β WWII killed β2.7%.
β The global drought & famine of 1876-78 killed β3.7%.
β The1918 flu pandemic killed β2% of world population.
β WWII killed β2.7%.
β The global drought & famine of 1876-78 killed β3.7%.
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 13/20β When I was a child, horrific famines were often in the news, in places like Bangladesh. But Bangladesh and India now have food surpluses, every year. Rising CO2 level is one of the reasons for that.
ourworldindata.org
rattibha.com
ourworldindata.org
rattibha.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 14/20β Elevated CO2 (eCO2) is beneficial for almost all ecosystems. In fact, eCO2 even helps pine forests withstand bark beetles.
academic.oup.com
academic.oup.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 15/20β We'll never get CO2 to anywhere near optimum (Cretaceous/Jurassic) levels, but the modest increase so far is helping both man and nature.
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 16/20β The imagined major harms of manmade climate change simply are not happening. For instance, sea-level trends haven't changed significantly since the 1920s.
#sealevel" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="event.stopPropagation()">sealevel.info
#sealevel" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="event.stopPropagation()">sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 17/20β The great Nobel laurate & climatology pioneer Svante Arrhenius foresaw the benefits of eCO2, way back in 1908.
tinyurl.com
tinyurl.com
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 18/20β Arrhenius even predicted "Arctic amplification" β the fortuitous fact that that warming from elevated CO2 is disproportionately at high latitudes, where it beneficially makes the frigid climates slightly less harsh, and makes growing seasons longer:
sealevel.info
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 19/20β The scientific evidence is compelling that manmade climate change is modest and benign, and CO2 emissions are net-beneficial, rather than harmful.
Here are some relevant papers:
sealevel.info
Here are some relevant papers:
sealevel.info
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @NatGeo 20/20β The best evidence shows that manmade climate change is real, but modest & benign, and CO2 emissions are highly beneficial.
The major harms are all merely hypothetical (& mostly implausible). The benefits are real, measured & very large.
The major harms are all merely hypothetical (& mostly implausible). The benefits are real, measured & very large.
@FactSparrow @Spencerfletch0 @Vieux_Rhone @ClimatePoet @OscarsWild1 @JoeTheAtheist @Albert_Redstone @Kenneth72712993 @insane_voice @PolAnimalAus @WadeKendall4 @AtomsksSanakan @JsharkJill @TheDisproof @NikolovScience @tracemetalclean @CymaticWave @Gladfly1 @PierreTherrie14 @GillesnFio @Tangomitteckel @DawnTJ90 @swcrisis @Tokyo_Tom @EthonRaptor @KCTaz @Foresaken1 @Jamz129 @dvibrationz @Schtickery @pinangodan @FrankWi74044551 @AOECOIN @Bananenrijperij @KGrumpallo @stevethib @FrankChanged @ElQuesoSabio @Creamih8 @Vulgar_wit @MATTP1949 @whyofweb @su_js1 @Silence54994655 @TyotoRiffle @AlanBlackMD @ideapalooza @Rattibha @ThreadReaderApp @Threader_app please unroll or compile this.
Loading suggestions...