Imām Uthmān b. Saīd ad-Dārimī (d. 280 A.H) said :
(As for your claims that they (ahl al-sunnah) speak of limbs composed of parts (jārihun murakkabun) then this is a type of disbelief not spoken of by any one of the Muslims. We do affirm hearing and seeing and an eye,
1/10
(As for your claims that they (ahl al-sunnah) speak of limbs composed of parts (jārihun murakkabun) then this is a type of disbelief not spoken of by any one of the Muslims. We do affirm hearing and seeing and an eye,
1/10
without a howness, just as He has affirmed it in what he revealed of His book, and what His Messenger sallalahu ‘alayhi wassalam affirmed for Him.
What you keep repeating over and over again, limbs, body parts and the like, hashw and fables and slander-is something no one
2/10
What you keep repeating over and over again, limbs, body parts and the like, hashw and fables and slander-is something no one
2/10
in the world speaks of.
We have narrated reports about the hearing and seeing and the eye in this book with their chains of narration and their wordings from Rasul Allah salllalahu ‘alayhi wassalam; so we only say as He said, and we mean by them what he meant,
3/10
We have narrated reports about the hearing and seeing and the eye in this book with their chains of narration and their wordings from Rasul Allah salllalahu ‘alayhi wassalam; so we only say as He said, and we mean by them what he meant,
3/10
but howness is lifted from them, and mentions of limbs and organs are unnecessary additions from your side-slanderous ones too).
——————
He also said : ( So say to this disputer : As for what you claim that these people claim Allah has an eye, then we only say so because
4/10
——————
He also said : ( So say to this disputer : As for what you claim that these people claim Allah has an eye, then we only say so because
4/10
Allah-the exalted- and His Messenger sallalahu ‘alayhi wassalam said so. As for body parts of the likes of the human eye which is composed of parts (jārihun kajārih il-aynī min al-insān ‘ala t-tarkīb) then this is a lie that you have deliberately imposed upon us, for you
5/10
5/10
full well know that no one says this, but you spare no effort in your slanders since this allows you to better spread your deviance in the hearts of the ignorant people.
Now lying is not permissible, not seriously nor in jest. So who exactly are these people whom you have
6/10
Now lying is not permissible, not seriously nor in jest. So who exactly are these people whom you have
6/10
heard speak of limbs made of parts (jārihun murakkabun) ? Show us who they are, since they are disbelievers. How many times will you keep repeating about a composite body, organs and limbs, about parts, (jismun murakkabun wa a’dhā’un,wa jawārihun wa-jzā’un) as if intending
7/10
7/10
to scare us away from attributing to Allah what He attributed to Himself and what the Messenger ﷺ attributed to Him, by this villification.
Even though we do not attribute to Allah a body of the likes of created bodies, nor with body parts nor limbs but we certainly
8/10
Even though we do not attribute to Allah a body of the likes of created bodies, nor with body parts nor limbs but we certainly
8/10
attribute to Him what enrages you of these attributes that you deny.
We say He is the One and Only, the Independent who does not beget nor was He begotten, He has no equal,
9/10
We say He is the One and Only, the Independent who does not beget nor was He begotten, He has no equal,
9/10
possessor of a magnanimous Face, the Hearer who hears, the Seer with vision, the Light of the heavens and earth).
Source: Naqd Uthman b. Saīd ‘ala-l-Marrīsi al-jahmī al-‘anid fīmā Iftarā ‘ala Allāhī fī at-Tawhīd.
The End
10/10
Source: Naqd Uthman b. Saīd ‘ala-l-Marrīsi al-jahmī al-‘anid fīmā Iftarā ‘ala Allāhī fī at-Tawhīd.
The End
10/10
Loading suggestions...