Aneesh Gokhale
Aneesh Gokhale

@authorAneesh

19 Tweets 55 reads Oct 14, 2021
How much nonsense can you write in ten lines ?
Here is the winner from NCERT :
Meanwhile Bhakti saint Namdev
Namdev lived from 1270 to 1350. Exactly the time Maharashtra got exposed to equality and brotherhood.
Hinduism faced a calamity due to Khilji invasion. Temples were broken, pilgrimage centres rendered desolate. The Bhakti movement, with its focus on simplicity kept people within the Hindu fold.
Ref : Shri Shiv Samarth Anonya Sambandh.
Here is the source of your simplicity.
Justice Ranade on importance of Bhakti movement. This pertains to Maratha history, but the base theme of keeping Hindus within Hinduism holds everywhere.
Hinduism has meaningless rites and rituals.
For example, Saraswati puja tomorrow, where many unassuming students will respectfully worship their NCERT textbooks.
(Note : Sarcasm)
Thanks @SuvarnBharat for the pic.
This is Class 7 book.
" At a time when invaders had obliterated the open display of Hindu religion, the Bhakti movement, through its simplicity of worship, kirtans and Bhajans, kept the masses within the Hindu fold"
- VK Rajwade.
Now this is not my domain of knowledge, but surely, if you are going back to Original Hinduism .. you would go to the Vedas (Including Yajurveda) rather than Upanishads no ?
According to this para, Monotheism is associated with equality. Conversely Polytheism is not. And rituals are also bad.
Very good.
One of Maharashtra's earliest and tallest historians
Awaiting confirmation this is the main NCERT Book.
But it definitely is a recommended reader , a worse system - in which schools can feed whatever they want to kids , no matter the change in central content.
@SuvarnBharat.
ICSE correction. The book is part of the syllabus.
Same thing.
Another thing : What's the deal with these recommended textbooks which schools can chose at their own whim and fancy ?Then what's the use of changing syllabus if any private pub " As per latest syllabus can pass"
Anyhow, Delhi Sultanate inspired Bhakti movement is a pet Commie theme. Have read such a book myself.
Aren't such recommended books vetted by the concerned boards ? Then what's the use of changing syllabus.
Correction - Recommended textbook under ICSE. So next question, does ICSE have no control over what passes under its name ??
Govt changes textbooks... Schools chose from a plethora of unvetted fairy tales and we end up with above.
This is a ICSE book. Still the point holds, why is it being taught at all.
Someone explain how these ICSE schools work ?
Any random drivel with a "As per ICSE syllabus" can be force fed as textbook to unassuming kids ?
What's the board there for ?
This passage is from a book used as a textbook for Class 7 , ICSE.
Whether ICSE or anyone else, Bhakti Movement = Caste has been a Commie theme and used frequently for whitewashing.
Below quote by Romila ji from a NYT article (NYT since then became a paid service)
While the main tweet is a ICSE school book, NCERT also doesn't touch on everything I have mentioned with sources in the thread
Rejected rituals, outward display of relgion etc... Doesn't tell us why.
NCERT .. Class 7.

Loading suggestions...