Wrong comparison. Both are Hindu Monuments. There are many points to prove Qutub minar as Hindu.
Some simple points...
Some simple points...
1. If Sultans built so grand edifice, Self obsessed Sultans couldnt build Royal palace for themselves in the place?
2. They must build it from the scrap after destroying the Jain & Hindu temples there, but the Minar intricacy cannot be brought on the scrap. So it existed already
2. They must build it from the scrap after destroying the Jain & Hindu temples there, but the Minar intricacy cannot be brought on the scrap. So it existed already
3. The expertise of this building alone cannot be seen any contemporary buildings of Sultans. The domes they built on destroyed temples don't stand today. How does minar still stand?
4. Leave alone stone carving, they have used only mud & stones to build structures which are ruined.
5. The smaller monuments that are seen are constructed by the local artisans under the nook of the Knife.
5. The smaller monuments that are seen are constructed by the local artisans under the nook of the Knife.
6. If they have really built the minar, the magnificence must have repeated in other places. It doesn't.
7. If they had such expertise couldn't have mughals built one such with so much time in their hands. Apart from Taj minars, they could built a Hiran Minar.
7. If they had such expertise couldn't have mughals built one such with so much time in their hands. Apart from Taj minars, they could built a Hiran Minar.
8. In reality the science behind Qutub minar could not be perceived by sultans to make one such anywhere.
9. It was a normal tradition to Indians to build such tall "Sthambhas" like Vijay sthambh, Kirti sthambh defying the gravity.
9. It was a normal tradition to Indians to build such tall "Sthambhas" like Vijay sthambh, Kirti sthambh defying the gravity.
10. Quoting examples like "Jam Minar" that was entirely built of bricks as the reason for Qutub minar is utter baseless. A Civil engineer can explain the complexities.
Chand minar in Daultabad, Jhulta minar in Amdabad, few other minars in Champaner cannot be used to justify the architectural excellence of Qutub minar. Its like comapring rat to Elephant. Even then all these are built by Indian artisans.
***
***
There are many architectural points to prove. Keeping all of them aside, just show me one minar constructed in this plan anywhere in India or Islamic world.
I will never bring the argument forth again.
"Only Indians have done this multiple times"
I will never bring the argument forth again.
"Only Indians have done this multiple times"
Loading suggestions...