Sitaram Goel- Intellectual or Hype
Thread
A section of So-Called Right-Wingers considers him a legend. Everyone takes this view unquestioned. This is a deep look into his life, works and comparison to know him better. Getting to know him without the glorified marketing.
Thread
A section of So-Called Right-Wingers considers him a legend. Everyone takes this view unquestioned. This is a deep look into his life, works and comparison to know him better. Getting to know him without the glorified marketing.
Firstly, I am not even equal to Sitaram Goel Ji's Foot Nail. Just like he was not equal to the Foot nail of Bose, Arya, RSS and many. Yet he criticised them all without a bother. Take this thread positively analysing his book "How I become Hindu" counter with facts, not abuses.
Sitaram Ji is marketed as some Legendary Hindu to ever walk on Bharat. But, he was indeed just another Secular Hindu. In his early youth, he wanted to burn all Hindu Scriptures. It was Arya Samaj who maintained him inside Hinduism as they did with many, even Musleems.
Sitaram Ji's highly intellectual fan following doesn't like bringing up his old ideas, as he changed later. But this is a 26-Year-old Man Sitaram's view, not some Teenager. Also If Modi Ji's Marriage, RSS's 50-year-old Articles can be questioned. Who the hell is he?
Marketed as Extreme Hindu. Sitaram Ji In Chapter 1, says, he never felt any Animosity towards Musleems. Because his neighbours were gentle.
In PostScript(PS): 1 he believed all have the same ancestry. Echoing the Same DNA theory of RSS, made fun of by his minions of today.
In PostScript(PS): 1 he believed all have the same ancestry. Echoing the Same DNA theory of RSS, made fun of by his minions of today.
Sitaram Goel Ji in his entire legendary life did not participate in anything. He was not a Freedom fighter during British Era. No Legendary Hindu Heroism during Partition(He ran away from His house In Calcutta).
If you thought he was some revolutionary Hero, he was nothing so.
If you thought he was some revolutionary Hero, he was nothing so.
During the Emergency, when even pet animals of RSS Karyakartas and other Organisations were being arrested and tortured. As Indira Gandhi saw them as a threat to her plans. Legendary intellectual 200 IQ Sitaram Goel Ji was free, building up his business.
A Journalist by profession, he actually writes, he held both Hindus and Momeens responsible for blood Shed. This does not matter because nobody gives a damn when someone vomits on paper for attention. Groundwork brings change. Also, read the title of this chapter 3 times.
Sitaram Ji criticised Netaji Shubash Chandra Bose. He did not consider him patriotic enough. All that building the army, fighting was not enough.
But, when Sitaram Ji had the chance to serve his country during the Indo-China war. He kind of chickened out because of family. (PS5)
But, when Sitaram Ji had the chance to serve his country during the Indo-China war. He kind of chickened out because of family. (PS5)
I had an image of Sitaram as some revolutionary, like Bhagat Singh Ji, Savarkar Ji, Azad, Tilak etc. Maybe he went to jail for many years, build some big team for Hindutva. As being marketed by his followers, who quotes his opinion on everything. As if his opinion means a lot.
After looking at his life, and books. I can say, he was nothing compared to what we call an intellectual.
An intellectual is someone who gives a solution, not mentions the problem. Neighbourhood Aunties can also tell us about the problems. But no Solutions..
An intellectual is someone who gives a solution, not mentions the problem. Neighbourhood Aunties can also tell us about the problems. But no Solutions..
Most of his books I read till now have no Info, No research, no figures or anything. Just plain views and opinions of himself.
Yes, he wrote against Eslam and Kristianity. But, that was no innovation. Maharishi Dayanand opened Bible and Kuraan page by page decades before him.
Yes, he wrote against Eslam and Kristianity. But, that was no innovation. Maharishi Dayanand opened Bible and Kuraan page by page decades before him.
Most of his books are inspired by Arya Samaj's comparative studies.
Rangeela Rasool, a Book against the Eslamic Pophet was published in 1927. The writer and his team faced death threats and one khilled too. This is what one calls a legend.
Rangeela Rasool, a Book against the Eslamic Pophet was published in 1927. The writer and his team faced death threats and one khilled too. This is what one calls a legend.
Guru Golvalkar wrote many books, he also travelled all Bharat. Build dozens of Unions, Student groups, and Samitis. Only to be called a group of fools by a loudmouth.
Savarkar wrote too, but spend many years in prison too. Formed groups that a Smoking addict can never do.
Savarkar wrote too, but spend many years in prison too. Formed groups that a Smoking addict can never do.
Sripad Damodar Satwalekar wrote 15+ books on Vedic Scriptures after thorough research and study. Ever heard of him?
Dr Surendra Kumar, researched for many years and compiled the ancient Mansusmriti for us to study. Ever heard?
Because they never chased Clout nor marketed.
Dr Surendra Kumar, researched for many years and compiled the ancient Mansusmriti for us to study. Ever heard?
Because they never chased Clout nor marketed.
From Partition till Ram Mandir Andolan. Sitaram Ji's has written more than 35+ books. I wish he had written at least 100. I wish he had Social Media at his time, we would have got a great Handle that criticises everything that moves inside Right-Wing.
Full respect for his works and contributions. But for my fellow Swayamsevaks and other Groundworkers. Such legends with opinions do not matter much.
Let the Blog Writers, Influencers from elite Sections of Right-Wing worship him. He represents them, he was them in his time.
Let the Blog Writers, Influencers from elite Sections of Right-Wing worship him. He represents them, he was them in his time.
I was waiting for someone to call it cherry Picking or use some good English word to cover their face. I have uploaded full Paragraphs, not Single lines. What else should I do, upload the full book?
And What same DNA be? SRG believed in Same DNA- PS 1
And What same DNA be? SRG believed in Same DNA- PS 1
Loading suggestions...