Objection: Prophet ﷺ LEARNED Urdu After Connection With Ulama Of Deoband.
[ THREAD ]
[ THREAD ]
Al Jawab :
First let me clear that
These objections are one of the age old objection by barelvis which have been answered many times. Even Barelvi scholars have left making such objections & then comes hazrat Irfan.
He comes to lick what was spitted out by barelvis years ago
First let me clear that
These objections are one of the age old objection by barelvis which have been answered many times. Even Barelvi scholars have left making such objections & then comes hazrat Irfan.
He comes to lick what was spitted out by barelvis years ago
﷽
1st thing to note is that it was a 'Dream'.
The actual ibarat what Fakhrul Muhaddiseen Allama khaleel ahmad Saharanpuri rahmatullahi alaihi has written is:
1st thing to note is that it was a 'Dream'.
The actual ibarat what Fakhrul Muhaddiseen Allama khaleel ahmad Saharanpuri rahmatullahi alaihi has written is:
"It was on account of this that a certain pious man saw Nabi ﷺ in a dream & saw him speaking in Urdu. He asked Nabi ﷺ, "How do
you know this language, you are Arab?"
He ﷺ replied, "This Language was known to me since I began dealing with the scholars of Deoband."
you know this language, you are Arab?"
He ﷺ replied, "This Language was known to me since I began dealing with the scholars of Deoband."
[Al-Barahin al-Qati„ah, p. 26-27.]
Let's understand principles of Dream under the light of Shari'ah.
1. In a hadees, it concludes that the pen is raised upon three people in which, there is a person who is asleep until he wakes up.
[ Mustadrak Al Haakim : Jild-Page-67/68 ]
1. In a hadees, it concludes that the pen is raised upon three people in which, there is a person who is asleep until he wakes up.
[ Mustadrak Al Haakim : Jild-Page-67/68 ]
Above hadith is sahih on condtions of 'Muslim'
Shame on such people, even Shari'ah has raised pen upon a person who is asleep. This hadith clears that there is no ruling on a dream.
Shame on such people, even Shari'ah has raised pen upon a person who is asleep. This hadith clears that there is no ruling on a dream.
Imam Ahle Sunnat Maulana Sarfraz Khan Safdar Rh writes:
"There is a form of dream & there is a reality in it which is called Ta'beer. Sometimes the dream seems to be very beautiful & exciting, but the reality is quite the opposite, +
"There is a form of dream & there is a reality in it which is called Ta'beer. Sometimes the dream seems to be very beautiful & exciting, but the reality is quite the opposite, +
and sometimes it happens that the dream looks very sad and horrible, But it's esoteric aspect and interpretation is very pleasant and there is no end to the happiness of the dreamer after the interpretation comes to light."
Here are some brief references to dreams of this second term:
See what a bad dream it was. Umm Fazl was also reluctant to narrate it but what an excellent Ta'beer (i.e. interpretation).
2.If a person sees in a dream that he is wearing handcufs, then of course the dreamer will be frightened, but Hazrat Abu Huraira Ra says that he likes handcuffs, but he dislikes the shackles around his neck. Handcuffs are proof of his steadfastness.
[Bukhari 2/1039; Muslim 2/241]
[Bukhari 2/1039; Muslim 2/241]
To keep it short we've only mentioned two dreams.
The Actual Interpretation!!!
Loading suggestions...