Freya Holmér
Freya Holmér

@FreyaHolmer

9 Tweets 1 reads Dec 15, 2022
I don't think I consider AI generated images art anymore. I just can't
at this point it feels like an insult to artists, I feel like they're just images you used an advanced search engine to find
I'm not allowing replies on this because this discourse is absolutely toxic and it makes me incredibly tired
I've had nothing but bad experiences from uncharitable people when talking about this in public
there is no way to criticize this whole development without being accused of gatekeeping, or for being against accessibility of art, or for being some sort of capitalist demon who wants to put work and effort between people and creative expression
"artists should just pivot to becoming AI art directors"
genuinely, from the bottom of my heart: fuck that
just say you don't give a damn about the craft, that all you really want is the shiny end result. more hollow fast-food content to consume at a rate never seen before
some mostly have issues with AI image gen when it comes to how it fits into capitalism and exploitation, but personally, I think it goes beyond that
I think AI has a great potential to empower artists, when it's a tool to help interpolate, refine, and extrapolate
AI upscaling? sure
AI background/artifact removal? great
AI context aware fill? yeah
AI taking over almost the entire creative process? no thanks
to me, there's more heart, humanity, and art in a napkin doodle, than there is in the most aesthetically algorithmically optimized AI images out there
"but photography"
in photography, you were there to take that picture, you chose the framing to convey a message, you usually choose the time of day, the location, you took something from the existing world and found your own angle to show something in a new light
unlike the AI
the few AI image gen projects that I *would* call art, isn't art because the image is an art piece, but because of the meta-narrative of the prompt, the framing, and the communication around it
so sure, it's possible to use AI to make art, but its output isn't art, in my view

Loading suggestions...