ET Money
ET Money

@ETMONEY

12 Tweets 2 reads Oct 14, 2022
Picking the right fund manager in NPS is crucial.
Reason: They are actively managed.
So, there could be a significant difference in their performance in the long term.
But how should you choose the right NPS fund manager?
A thread ๐Ÿงตanalyzing their performances.
As an investor, you primarily have the following investment choice.
1. Corporate bonds (Scheme C)
2. Govt bonds (Scheme G)
3. Equity (Scheme E)
You can also invest a small portion (up to 5%) in alternative assets like REITs, InvITs, etc.
Currently, there are 10 pension fund managers, with Axis Pension Fund being the latest entrant.
To help you pick the best fund manager, letโ€™s dissect their performances in the three key asset classesโ€”equity, corporate bond and government bond.
Letโ€™s start with equity (Scheme E).
We took NIFTY 50 TRI as a benchmark to measure the performance of NPS funds.
And we found that almost all NPS Funds have underperformed the NIFTY 50 index.
Check table. ๐Ÿ‘‡
Interestingly, the returns of all NPS fund managers are very close to one another.
Nonetheless, HDFC Pension Management seems to stand out.
HDFC is the only fund that has outperformed NIFTY 50 in 7 years.
And it has been the most consistent as well.
See table. ๐Ÿ‘‡
Nonetheless, NPS is not all about equity.
You also invest a sizable corpus in corporate debt and government debt.
Letโ€™s look at their performance.
Govt Bond (Scheme G)
For this asset type, we took two debt fund categories that primarily invest in G-Secs to compare the performance
Result: NPS funds have outperformed their mutual fund counterparts
Among individual funds, LIC Pension Fund stands out, followed by HDFC
๐Ÿ‘‡
Corporate Bonds (Scheme C)
We took the Corporate Bond Fund category as the benchmark.
Here, too, NPS funds have done better than their mutual fund counterparts.
Among individual funds, ICICI Pru stands out in the long run. But HDFC and ABSL are doing better lately.
๐Ÿ‘‡
How do you pick the best NPS fund?
In NPS, you primarily invest in a mix of equity, corporate debt and government bonds.
And you can decide which asset you want to invest in the most or least.
Thus, your choice of fund manager should be driven by your preferred asset mix.
Opt for a fund manager based on the asset in which you will predominantly invest.
If you go for a higher allocation to equities, look at funds that have performed well in Scheme E.
The same holds for other asset types.
Every actively managed fund goes through periods of underperformance.
As an NPS investor, you get the option to change the fund manager once every financial year.
But donโ€™t switch unless a fund manager underperforms for a long period (at least 2 years).
If you found this useful, please like, share, and retweet the first tweet to help us reach more readers.๐Ÿ˜‡
For more threads, follow us.๐Ÿ‘‡
Also, click on the bell icon in the profile section, so you don't miss any threads. ๐Ÿ””

Loading suggestions...