Firstly, this Hadīth was narrated by al-Bukhārī, Muslim, Abu Dawūd, al-Nasā‘ī, Ibn Abī Shaybah, al-Bazzār, al-Humaydī, al-Tahāwī, Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, Abu Ya’lā, al-Bayhaqī, Abu Nu’aym and others
Time to throw out all the books of Sunan?
Time to throw out all the books of Sunan?
A similar issue happened with al-Shaykh Nūr al-Dīn Itr in a conference with a Sunnah rejector.
The Sunnah rejector made this long speech on how al-Bukhārī fabricated this and al-Bukhārī did this, did that, it has this Hadīth, that issue, this issue..
The Sunnah rejector made this long speech on how al-Bukhārī fabricated this and al-Bukhārī did this, did that, it has this Hadīth, that issue, this issue..
So Shaykh Nūr al-Dīn briefly and intelligently asked him: Put aside al-Bukhārī, was there this same issue with Muslim? al-Tirmidhī? Ibn Mājah?
Second point, al-Hāfidh Abu Nu’aym al-Haddād wrote a book called Jāmi’ al-Sahīhayn
What he did in this book is that he narrated the same Ahādīth from al-Bukhārī in his Sahīh, while stepping over al-Bukhārī in narration.
What he did in this book is that he narrated the same Ahādīth from al-Bukhārī in his Sahīh, while stepping over al-Bukhārī in narration.
This will become clearer with this same Hadīth that has been brought forward
First image is al-Bukhārī, second is Abu Nu’aym
Now both these are the same Hadīth, but they have different chains
First image is al-Bukhārī, second is Abu Nu’aym
Now both these are the same Hadīth, but they have different chains
Abu Nu’aym narrates this Hadīth directly from al-Bukhārī's teachers, sidestepping al-Bukhārī
In this case it's Hāshim Ibn Hāshim, see how both chains meet at him
Remember, same Hadīth.
In this case it's Hāshim Ibn Hāshim, see how both chains meet at him
Remember, same Hadīth.
So essentially what we have here, is proof that al-Bukhārī was not fabricating Ahādīth and bringing them out of thin air, rather he is taking them directly from his teachers, to the Prophet ﷺ, including this Hadīth.
Note: there are many works in this style. Mustakhrajāt.
Note: there are many works in this style. Mustakhrajāt.
I repeat, attacking al-Imām al-Bukhārī is attacking Islām.
نسأل الله السلام.
نسأل الله السلام.
Loading suggestions...