🧵Thread ➠ The Companions of The Infallible Imams of AhlulBayt ⚑
@Whitedr26188014 is out here criticizing AhluSunnah wal-Jama’a for not mentioning the conflicts and tribulations that occurred between the Companions of the Prophet (عليه وعليهم الصلاة والسلام).
I already posted a thread in response to this issue 👇
I already posted a thread in response to this issue 👇
But I find it quite interesting how this individual and his likes refuse to mention the crimes done by the companions of his infallible imams.
That is why I decided to make this thread, so that we can see if they will be consistent and reject the narrations of these individuals.
That is why I decided to make this thread, so that we can see if they will be consistent and reject the narrations of these individuals.
𝟙• Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani:
One of their narrators, Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani was deemed trustworthy by Muhammad al-Jawahiri!
He said: "Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani: He narrated 250 narration some from Abu Ja’far and Abu Abdellah. He is Ibrahim Ibn Nu’aym al-‘Abdi, the trustworthy one."
One of their narrators, Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani was deemed trustworthy by Muhammad al-Jawahiri!
He said: "Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani: He narrated 250 narration some from Abu Ja’far and Abu Abdellah. He is Ibrahim Ibn Nu’aym al-‘Abdi, the trustworthy one."
Now that we know that this individual is trustworthy, let us see if Zulfiqar and his likes will condemn him.
Qutb a-Deen a-Rawandi narrated that Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani said: "One day I went to the door of Abu Ja’far al-Baqir (as) and I knocked on it[…]
Qutb a-Deen a-Rawandi narrated that Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani said: "One day I went to the door of Abu Ja’far al-Baqir (as) and I knocked on it[…]
So Wasifah Nahid came out to me so I slapped the head of her breast and I said to her: «Tell your master that I’m at his door». So he (the Imam) shouted from inside the house: «Come in! You have no mother». So I entered and said: «O my master, by God, I didn’t mean to doubt[…]
nor was I seeking anything but an increase in my certainty». He said: «You’re truthful, if you thought that these walls are a barrier to our sights just as how it’s a barrier to your sight then in that case there’s no difference between you and us! So do not do it again!»."
So Abu a-Sabah al-Kinani’s excuse for touching the female servant’s breast was to make sure that the Imam has the knowledge of the unseen to be able to see him through the walls.
If this happened with one the Prophet’s ﷺ companions I wonder what Zulfiqar and his likes would do?
If this happened with one the Prophet’s ﷺ companions I wonder what Zulfiqar and his likes would do?
𝟚• Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam:
A-Najashi said in his book of rijal: "Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam al-Asadi, he is know as Ibn Abi Burdah, trustworthy trustworthy, he narrated from Abu Abdellah and Abu al-Hasan, peace be upon both, and he lived a lengthy life."
A-Najashi said in his book of rijal: "Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam al-Asadi, he is know as Ibn Abi Burdah, trustworthy trustworthy, he narrated from Abu Abdellah and Abu al-Hasan, peace be upon both, and he lived a lengthy life."
Contemporary Shia scholar, Muhammad Ali al-Abtahi said: "Al-Barqi mentioned him (i.e. Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam) among the companions of a-Sadiq (peace be upon him), and the Shaykh (a-Najashi) mentioned him among the companions of al-Kadhim (peace be upon him)."
What’s surprising is that this companion did the exact same thing which the previous had done with the female servant!
Qutb a-Deen a-Rawandi said: "Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam al-Asadi said: «I came to Medina and I went to the door of Abu Abdellah (peace e upon him)[…]
Qutb a-Deen a-Rawandi said: "Ibrahim Ibn Mihzam al-Asadi said: «I came to Medina and I went to the door of Abu Abdellah (peace e upon him)[…]
I tried opening, so a female servant came to open the door, thus I pinched her breast and I entered»."
𝟛• Uthman Ibn Eissa:
Zulfiqar has been seen accusing Abu Bakr (ra) of stealing Fatima’s (as) wealth when he refused to give her Fadak.
What if I were to show you that Uthman Ibn Eissa also stole the Imam’s wealth, never gave it back, never repented, and he is still accepted!
Zulfiqar has been seen accusing Abu Bakr (ra) of stealing Fatima’s (as) wealth when he refused to give her Fadak.
What if I were to show you that Uthman Ibn Eissa also stole the Imam’s wealth, never gave it back, never repented, and he is still accepted!
Al-Khoei said about this individual:"There must be no doubt that ‘Uthman Ibn Issa was misguided from the truth and was an opponent to Imam a-Rida (peace be upon him), and he never accepted his imamah, and he stole the money of the imam and did not return it to him! […]
And as for his repentance and him returning the money afterwards then this isn’t confirmed. That’s because it’s from the narration of Nasr Ibn a-Sabah and he’s nothing (in hadith)[…]
And after all that, he was still trustworthy according to the testimony of the Shaykh and Ali Ibn Ibrahim and Ibn ShahrAshub which is supported by the claim that he is from the people of ijmaa’ (narrators whose trustworthiness is agreed upon among the shia scholars of hadith)."
Muhammad al-Jawahiri said: "Uthman Ibn Eissa: He was a scholar of the waqifah sect. He was a deviant from the truth and opponent of a-Rida (as)[…]
His repentance isn’t confirmed but despite all of that he trustworthy due to the testimony of the Shaykh and Ali Ibn Ibrahim and Ibn ShahrAshub."
This is just a fraction of what has been narrated about the companions of the infallible Imams from whom the Shia take the ahadith of Ahlulbayt from.
InshaAllah in my next thread I’ll post more about this issue so that we can see if they still want to take about the Sahaba (ra).
InshaAllah in my next thread I’ll post more about this issue so that we can see if they still want to take about the Sahaba (ra).
Loading suggestions...