Once 50% vertical limit is allowed to be breached with DYC making Article 15(4)&16(4) a fundamental right than an exception to the rule of equality of opportunity along with redefining "efficiency" in article 335 when he takes up the TN & EWS case in a 11 judge bench.
It is over.
It is over.
And this will 100% happen and the govt won't know what hit it.
Ideally by now if there was a thinking UC lobby rather than a bunch of dumbfks, anonymized performance data of govt clgs,jobs in the form of a report would show the mismatch effect & also its ramifications on society.
Ideally by now if there was a thinking UC lobby rather than a bunch of dumbfks, anonymized performance data of govt clgs,jobs in the form of a report would show the mismatch effect & also its ramifications on society.
This is why EWS vertical quota was a mistake, you cannot expect to defend that and the oppose TN 69% quota. 50% vertical limit has to be "sacrosanct" which the govt said was not.
TN 69% approval means it can expand it further, similarly for other states.
TN 69% approval means it can expand it further, similarly for other states.
Then no option is left but to slowly keep increasing OBC quota at the central level until population proportion is reached.
Article 335 being amended perhaps even opens the door to resvns in the Military.
BJP is clueless.
Even private clgs have not been spared in EWS judgement.
Article 335 being amended perhaps even opens the door to resvns in the Military.
BJP is clueless.
Even private clgs have not been spared in EWS judgement.
Demands?
1. Reaffirm ambedkar's speech in the court where he said 50% crossing would swallow up the rule of equality of opportunity thereby making 50% limit permanent.
2. Wargame a case on banning pvt sector quota & use a proxy org to file the case & get it sorted judicially.
1. Reaffirm ambedkar's speech in the court where he said 50% crossing would swallow up the rule of equality of opportunity thereby making 50% limit permanent.
2. Wargame a case on banning pvt sector quota & use a proxy org to file the case & get it sorted judicially.
3.For buttressing 1 use data replicated over a decade from IITs IIMs where population proportional quota for one segment has led to horrible outcomes for them.
4. Premier institutions and brand because of the performance of the top 50% not the other half, hence limit necessary.
4. Premier institutions and brand because of the performance of the top 50% not the other half, hence limit necessary.
5. Article 335 objective definition of efficiency further allows you to set a minimum floor ceiling and avoid below scenario of -ve cutoffs
6. File a proxy petition again and undo the amendment passed by Vajpayee in 2001 citing 5 and this graph below and data from other exams.
6. File a proxy petition again and undo the amendment passed by Vajpayee in 2001 citing 5 and this graph below and data from other exams.
7. Pass a law that allows seat sliding if not enough candidates are crossing minimum threshold to be shifted unto the next category.
ST to SC to OBC to Gen.
Don't keep seats vacant.
Will also improve the quality of intake in preparatory courses which also need to be overhauled.
ST to SC to OBC to Gen.
Don't keep seats vacant.
Will also improve the quality of intake in preparatory courses which also need to be overhauled.
8. If you manage to get the 50% limit enshrined and EWS vertical is removed by a 11 judge bench, subcategorize OBC quota into 4 parts and similarly for SC/ST quota ofcourse with the sliding rule.
9. And to close the reservation issue for good, impose 3 horizontal EWS slabs.
9. And to close the reservation issue for good, impose 3 horizontal EWS slabs.
10. Final point-since EWS students have already entered & will graduate in 2023, due to cutoff differential mismatch will show up for them as well therefore busting discrimination as a reason for non performance.
Root cause of bad grades is pairing the top 0.1% with the top 1%.
Root cause of bad grades is pairing the top 0.1% with the top 1%.
Loading suggestions...